Indian selectors may turn to domestic stars after South Africa loss

India’s Test selectors, led by Ajit Agarkar, may turn to seasoned domestic stars like Ruturaj Gaikwad, Rajat Patidar and Rinku Singh after the South Africa whitewash. Experts stress the need for specialists over all-rounders to strengthen the batting line-up

New Delhi: Specialists could be back in vogue in Indian Test cricket after the series whitewash against South Africa as the Ajit Agarkar-led selection panel recalibrates its approach towards crucial positions like the number three slot in the batting line-up.

The spot, which was sealed by the likes of Rahul Dravid and Cheteshwar Pujara for the better part of the last three decades, is now up for grabs.

---

Karun Nair could not clinch it in England despite being given four Tests and B Sai Sudharsan, with an average of 27 across 11 innings, has shown that he is still very much a work in progress.

There are technical issues in his game, especially on spin-friendly sub-continental tracks, and he needs time in domestic cricket and with the pathways team (India A) to get ready for Tests.

Test cricket is not a place to correct elementary mistakes when stakes are high, and India have been learning this in the most painful way possible.

There is a strong possibility that the selection committee will now seriously consider seasoned domestic names to lend solidity to the line-up going forward.

While doors are mostly shut on Sarfaraz Khan and Abhimanyu Easwaran, three battle-hardened domestic veterans — Ruturaj Gaikwad, Rajat Patidar and Rinku Singh — could keep the team management interested.

Among the new crop of red-ball players, Smaran Ravichandran (first-class average 78) and Yash Rathod (960 runs last Ranji season) have prolific numbers as middle-order batters.

“People might blame Ajit and his committee for not selecting Abhimanyu and Sarfaraz but then do the head coach (Gautam Gambhir) and new captain (Shubman Gill) have faith in their abilities? If not, what will Ajit alone do?” asked a former selector familiar with the system.

Possibly, time has come to go back to the drawing board and bank on specialists rather than placing faith in non-existent all-rounders.

“Let’s be clear on one thing, Kapil Dev was the last world-class all-rounder and the last competent Test-level all-rounder was Manoj Prabhakar, who could open batting and bowling.

“In case of Hardik Pandya, his body did not permit him to carry on,” the former selector said.

“But Nitish Reddy is a bits-and-pieces guy. He can play at best T20s, not even ODIs, and Gautam needs to understand that,” he added.

Reddy’s batting average in 10 Tests is 26, largely due to that hundred in Australia, and he has bowled only 86 overs in 15 innings, which is not even six overs on average. The stats indicate that Reddy is not proficient in either department.

Those in Delhi cricket, who have seen Gambhir operate, know about his fascination for all-rounders.

“When Gauti was Delhi captain, he liked the idea of all-rounders more than the actual all-rounders. Remember Manan Sharma? He was more of a left-arm spinner but Gauti made him bat No 3 for some time before he was dumped for good,” a former Delhi teammate recalled.

Need for specialists At this point, the need of the hour for the Test team is a proper, tough number three and a reserve number five, who will give the team solidity when required.

Ruturaj Gaikwad is believed to be the player who can be a stable number three with an average of 45-plus in 43 first-class games. He has already scored two hundreds and a 90-plus in Ranji Trophy this season, is a reasonably successful IPL captain, has played for India and looks like a man with the right mindset.

Second name is Rajat Patidar, whose first coming in Tests was not very encouraging. He was in the middle of a tremendous domestic season when he got injured but is expected to get fit soon. He already has a 45-plus average across 74 first-class games.

Last but not the least is Rinku Singh, who enjoys a near-60 first-class average in 52 games.

But to pick these proven performers, Gambhir and Gill need to take a leap of faith. The youth-only policy, at times, only looks good on paper, as seen in the South Africa series where only Washington Sundar looked the part.

“You will be a fool if you take every Gauti statement at face value. He can be ruthless if there is non-performance. Before you know, you might see Sudharsan and Reddy fall by the wayside come 2026. He only backs performers,” the former selector said.

When asked if he sees a Gaikwad, Patidar or Rinku making the cut, he quipped, “Sitting in November, you want me to second guess how Gauti’s mind will work in August next year? Only a soothsayer can do that.”