Monday, Nov 16, 2026
English News
  • Hyderabad
  • Telangana
  • AP News
  • India
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Sport
  • Science and Tech
  • Business
  • Rewind
  • ...
    • NRI
    • View Point
    • cartoon
    • My Space
    • Education Today
    • Reviews
    • Property
    • Lifestyle
E-Paper
  • NRI
  • View Point
  • cartoon
  • My Space
  • Reviews
  • Education Today
  • Property
  • Lifestyle
Home | View Point | Opinion Grey Zone Of Warfare

Opinion: ‘Grey zone’ of warfare

Below-the-threshold activities at sea must be addressed in the swiftest and strongest possible way

By Telangana Today
Published Date - 4 December 2024, 11:55 PM
Opinion: ‘Grey zone’ of warfare
whatsapp facebook twitter telegram

By Basil Germond

Russian President Vladimir Putin has claimed that Russia now has the right to target assets of nations that supply Ukraine with tactical missiles after the US authorised the use of such weapons against targets deep into Russian territory. So far Putin’s warning feels like a rhetorical escalation, which might not yet result in a direct military confrontation. But short of a “real” war, Moscow can destabilise Western economies and societies with operations in what is called the “grey zone”.


The grey zone is not defined geographically. It is a functional space between war and peace, where jurisdictions are blurred, contested or left unclear and where responsibilities and accountability are vague and deniable. It’s where hybrid warfare and below-the-threshold operations flourish, because it is more difficult to tell whether an attack has occurred and who might be responsible.

Hybrid Warfare

Hybrid warfare comes in myriad different forms. It can be disinformation campaigns designed to create uncertainty or even panic in a population. Or cyberattacks against transport infrastructure intended to seriously disrupt a competitor or adversary.

The maritime domain is often an important theatre for this kind of warfare. The sea is vast and uninhabitable (and in part unmapped) which makes it hard to survey, monitor and control. Contested and overlapping jurisdictions — for example in the Arctic or South China Sea — make it hard to clearly identify responsibilities. “Fish cross borders”, as do those who fish, and coastguards.

The maritime domain is a perfect playground for a country whose objective is to undermine the prosperity, cohesion or security of an adversary without risking a direct confrontation

The same is true of people smugglers, drug traffickers and spy ships. What’s more, a multitude of actors are involved in the governance of complex maritime supply chains, from naval forces to shipping companies, from maritime insurers to communication cable operators. This complexity is particularly salient in the shipping sector. Ships can fly the flag of one country and at the same time be owned and insured by a company from another country. They can have a multinational crew, and transport a cargo whose origin is hardly traceable to any specific state.

So the maritime domain is a perfect playground for a country whose objective is to undermine the prosperity, cohesion or security of an adversary without risking a direct confrontation.

Vulnerabilities at Sea

The maritime supply chains and infrastructure on which most nations are dependent for their security and prosperity are under threat. To take the UK as an example, 90% of its trade by volume is seaborne. Yet relatively unsophisticated non-state groups such as the Houthi rebels in Yemen have managed to disrupt freedom of navigation in the Red Sea, generating disproportionate costs to the global economy.

About 97% of the UK’s internet communication transits via undersea cables, which are increasingly targeted by hostile players. On November 15, the Yantar, described by Russia as an “oceanographic research vessel”, was escorted away from critical undersea cables in the Irish Sea. It is very unlikely that the ship was directly involved in sabotage since it operated in plain sight. Instead, its likely functions are to map important Western maritime infrastructure and — crucially — to send the message that Russia is ready to take risks and operate in the West’s backyard.

On November 17, the suspected sabotage of undersea cables in the Baltic Sea created suspicion over a cargo ship registered in China and owned by a Chinese company. It started its journey near St Petersburg in Russia and sailed in the area when the incident occurred. The Danish authorities reacted quickly to stop the ship before it left the Baltic Sea. While a chain of accountability has not yet been established, there might be a better chance to trace back responsibilities this time around.

Establishing Responsibility

This incident demonstrates two things: the limits of hybrid warfare and the fact that Western countries are ramping up their ability to respond in a timely manner to such incidents.

Being able to establish responsibility is key to this. Maritime surveillance as well as navies maintaining active presence at sea as well as the capacity to respond to incidents in the fastest possible way all play a role in making it harder to conduct hybrid warfare in a deniable way.

Another notable example was the rapid German response to a suspicious drone following the UK aircraft carrier HMS Queen Elizabeth into the port of Hamburg on November 24. All these incidents suggest the extent to which tensions are steadily rising between Russia and the West in the grey zone. The direction and firmness of NATO’s response to hybrid warfare and sabotage will be decisive. Hybrid war at sea entails many uncertainties about jurisdictions and responsibilities as well as the identity, motives, way of operating and capabilities of actual and potential perpetrators.

Grey zone activities create uncertainties and fears. And because of this they can disrupt the global economy, weaken societal cohesion and degrade the West’s ability to respond to security threats in a decisive way. This is why below-the-threshold activities at sea must be addressed in the swiftest and strongest possible way — to prevent deniability.

Basil Germond

(The author is Professor of International Security, Department of Politics, Philosophy and Religion, Lancaster University. theconversation.com)

Join Our Whatsapp Channel
  • Follow Us :
As preferred source
  • Tags
  • cyberattacks
  • disinformation
  • grey zone
  • hybrid warfare

Related News

  • Xi, Trump, Putin to hold first-ever trilateral meet on Nov 19

    Xi, Trump, Putin to hold first-ever trilateral meet on Nov 19

  • Europe pushes for seat at Ukraine peace talks but lacks unified voice

    Europe pushes for seat at Ukraine peace talks but lacks unified voice

  • Russia’s top independent newspaper closes its office after three decades, citing official pressure

    Russia’s top independent newspaper closes its office after three decades, citing official pressure

  • US-brokered talks are set to start in Abu Dhabi to discuss Ukraine-Russia peace deal

    US-brokered talks are set to start in Abu Dhabi to discuss Ukraine-Russia peace deal

Latest News

  • Amitabh Bachchan recalls near-drowning experience while kayaking in Nepal

    21 minutes ago
  • Anthropic promises to pursue humanity’s benefit. Its IPO filing gives it wiggle room

    22 minutes ago
  • Hyderabad: Newly purchased car rams into medical shop in Ramnagar, woman injured

    27 minutes ago
  • Trapped in love affair by Pakistani handler, Punjab woman lures boyfriend to blast train in Rajasthan

    31 minutes ago
  • Sai Pallavi discloses her mom got upset with her decision to cut her hair for her character in ‘Om’

    49 minutes ago
  • Jay Shah reappointed unopposed as ICC Chair for second term

    51 minutes ago
  • Army opens fire after suspicious movement near LoC in J&K’s Poonch

    1 hour ago
  • India eye historic third consecutive SAFF Championship title against Pakistan

    58 minutes ago

company

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

business

  • Subscribe

telangana today

  • Telangana
  • Hyderabad
  • Latest News
  • Entertainment
  • World
  • Andhra Pradesh
  • Science & Tech
  • Sport

follow us

  • Telangana Today Telangana Today
Telangana Today Telangana Today

© Copyrights 2024 TELANGANA PUBLICATIONS PVT. LTD. All rights reserved. Powered by Veegam

Telangana Today App