Monday, Nov 16, 2026
English News
  • Hyderabad
  • Telangana
  • AP News
  • India
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Sport
  • Science and Tech
  • Business
  • Rewind
  • ...
    • NRI
    • View Point
    • cartoon
    • My Space
    • Education Today
    • Reviews
    • Property
    • Lifestyle
E-Paper
  • NRI
  • View Point
  • cartoon
  • My Space
  • Reviews
  • Education Today
  • Property
  • Lifestyle
Home | Editorials | Editorial Poll Panels Overreach

Editorial: Poll panel’s overreach

On the face of it, the Election Commission’s move to make political parties accountable for their poll promises appears well-intended but it amounts to overreach. The poll panel is not the right body to decide what freebies are to be allowed or what should be the cap on such spending. It is for the political […]

By Telangana Today
Published Date - 7 October 2022, 12:30 AM
Editorial: Poll panel’s overreach
whatsapp facebook twitter telegram

On the face of it, the Election Commission’s move to make political parties accountable for their poll promises appears well-intended but it amounts to overreach. The poll panel is not the right body to decide what freebies are to be allowed or what should be the cap on such spending. It is for the political parties and the elected governments to devise and implement welfare policies that are not only beneficial to the vulnerable sections of society but also reflect fiscal responsibility. The enactment of the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act is a classic example of legislative accountability and the maturity of parties in adhering to it. The EC, as a constitutional body, is entrusted with the responsibility of conducting free and fair polls in the country and preventing people with criminal antecedents from entering the poll fray. The experience in the last few years of the NDA rule shows that the poll panel has not exactly covered itself in glory. From the heydays of the legendary TN Seshan, the standards of the Election Commission have, unfortunately, fallen, with several contentious decisions going in favour of the ruling dispensation. While there can be no two opinions about the need to weed out unreasonable freebies as they take a heavy toll on the States’ fiscal health, it would be imprudent on the part of any constitutional body to dictate the welfare agendas to political parties. Moreover, the relevance and viability of freebies vary from State to State and it would be impractical to prescribe a uniform policy for the country.

The EC has sought modifications in the Model Code of Conduct and asked the parties to quantify their poll promises, explain their source of funding and assess their impact on the fiscal sustainability of the State. It must be pointed out that a manifesto is much more than just a few promises, entailing financial costs. In a democracy, it is supposed to serve as a vision document with both subjective and objective elements. It is about the party’s convictions, and the salience it attaches to certain issues. It would be outside the purview of the poll body to curb the political and economic imagination or specify parameters for poll promises. Given the present levels of poverty, unemployment and huge inequalities, welfarism will drive the political economy. Moreover, defining freebies is impossible, and terming any promise as an “irrational freebie” is fraught with contestation and open to interpretation. A promise of one political party may be an irrational freebie for another and vice versa. If democracy is a contestation of ideas, free and fair elections would mean that political parties slug it out to debunk one idea over the other, and draw the voters’ attention with their own vision. There should be a level playing field for political parties.

Also Read

  • Editorial: New voice for new India

Join Our Whatsapp Channel
  • Follow Us :
As preferred source
  • Tags
  • Election Commission
  • FRBM

Related News

  • EC tells SC voters left out of draft rolls can reapply without prosecution

    EC tells SC voters left out of draft rolls can reapply without prosecution

  • EC extends MCC restrictions to retired officials, government appointees

    EC extends MCC restrictions to retired officials, government appointees

  • EC extends Andhra Pradesh SIR timeline, final electoral roll due on November 30

    EC extends Andhra Pradesh SIR timeline, final electoral roll due on November 30

  • INDIA Bloc won’t back down on Gyanesh Kumar removal campaign, says Venugopal

    INDIA Bloc won’t back down on Gyanesh Kumar removal campaign, says Venugopal

Latest News

  • Delhi temperature dips to seasonal low of 14.8°C as air quality remains poor

    8 minutes ago
  • Apple partners with OpenEvidence for AI-powered health research study

    17 minutes ago
  • Mohammed Shami likely to join Rajasthan Royals ahead of IPL 2027 retention deadline

    25 minutes ago
  • Anupama Ramachandran aims to defend women’s world snooker title

    27 minutes ago
  • BRS raises concern over worsening drinking water crisis in Hyderabad

    30 minutes ago
  • Amar Singh Devanda scripts history with 155.6-km run at Hyderabad Stadium Run

    53 minutes ago
  • Hyderabad: Doctor among five held for drugging Grindr dates with spiked beer, stealing gold

    59 minutes ago
  • Telangana swimmer Karthik Agneya creates history with three gold medals at Goa Swimathon

    1 hour ago

company

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

business

  • Subscribe

telangana today

  • Telangana
  • Hyderabad
  • Latest News
  • Entertainment
  • World
  • Andhra Pradesh
  • Science & Tech
  • Sport

follow us

  • Telangana Today Telangana Today
Telangana Today Telangana Today

© Copyrights 2024 TELANGANA PUBLICATIONS PVT. LTD. All rights reserved. Powered by Veegam

Telangana Today App